Insights

Robert Izsak on Maintaining Older Housing in New York City

I am Robert Izsak, a real estate owner in Brooklyn, and I want to write carefully about a subject that is often discussed in slogans: what it actually costs to keep older rental housing in New York City in decent condition. The work does not happen by wish. It happens when there is a plan, and when there is enough money to carry the plan out. The facts that follow are public and well documented. They are not a portrait of any one property, including my own.

A large share of the city lives in this housing

The 2023 New York City Housing and Vacancy Survey, conducted by the U.S. Census Bureau for the city, estimated 996,600 rent-stabilized apartments. That was about 41 percent of rental units and about 27 percent of the city’s overall housing stock. Rent stabilization generally applies to units in buildings of six or more apartments built before 1974, under the Emergency Tenant Protection Act, though other units are stabilized because of affordable-housing or tax-incentive programs.

Those figures are estimates, and the survey itself reports margins of error. Even so, the scale is not in doubt. A very large part of New York’s rental housing is older, regulated, and still in use. That is a basic fact about how the city is housed.

Older buildings also have a particular kind of economy. Roofs, boilers, facades, plumbing stacks, electrical service, and windows all have a life cycle. Some of that work can be postponed for a season. It cannot be postponed forever without showing up in the condition of the building and in the daily life of the people who live there.

The costs are regular, and they are not only the visible ones

Each year, the New York City Rent Guidelines Board studies the income and expenses of buildings that contain rent-stabilized apartments, using official tax filings, and it publishes a Price Index of Operating Costs. Those reports are the city’s most consistent public window into what it costs to run this stock. They group expenses in familiar categories: taxes, labor, utilities, fuel, insurance, maintenance, and administration, among others.

In the Board’s 2026 Income and Expense Study, which reports figures for 2024, taxes were the largest share of operating costs among buildings that contain stabilized units, and maintenance was the next largest among the major categories. The same study is careful to note that average costs, reported on a per-unit basis, can include expenses tied to commercial space in mixed buildings. I mention that caveat because precision matters here. A number that is useful as a citywide picture is not a budget for a particular walk-up in Brooklyn.

The public data make clear the shape of the work. The regular costs of taxes, insurance, fuel, and labor arrive whether or not a capital project is underway. On top of those come the capital items older buildings eventually require. A new roof, a heating plant, or a facade repair is not an upgrade in the marketing sense. It is the cost of keeping the building closed to the weather and functioning through another decade.

Policy sets the rules; maintenance still has to be funded

Rent stabilization exists to keep a large part of the city’s housing affordable and predictable for tenants. That purpose is real, and so are the legal duties that come with owning rental property: habitability, heat and hot water, and the housing-maintenance standards the city enforces. I do not think those duties are optional, and I do not think a serious discussion of building economics should treat them as an inconvenience.

It is also a fact that the rules for how owners recover certain improvement costs have changed. The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, among other things, limited the circumstances under which apartments can leave rent stabilization and changed the way major capital improvements and individual apartment improvements may affect rents. Reasonable people disagree about those changes. What should not be controversial is the arithmetic that remains after them: repairs and replacements still have to be paid for. If the income of a building cannot support the work the building needs, the work is delayed, reduced, or left to the next owner. None of those outcomes is good for the people living there.

I am not going to invent a citywide figure for how many buildings are in that tight position, or claim a single cause. Conditions and finances vary by age of building, by borough, and by how much of a property is regulated. A serious owner has to look at the actual building, not at an average, and then fund the work that building requires.

What careful ownership looks like in that math

The practical response is not a speech. It is a budget that includes both the ordinary year and the extraordinary one that is coming. It is a maintenance calendar, which I have written about separately, so that a roof is not a surprise. It is an honest view of energy costs, which are both an operating line and, in larger buildings, a regulatory one. And it is a refusal to treat cosmetic work as a substitute for the systems that actually keep a property livable.

Tenants are right to expect a building that functions. Owners are right to point out that functioning buildings have costs, and that those costs have been rising in categories the Rent Guidelines Board itself tracks, including insurance, taxes, and skilled labor. The useful middle is not a victory for one side. It is a building that is funded well enough to be maintained, and maintained well enough to be a stable home.

That is the standard I try to apply in my own work in Brooklyn. The city’s older housing will still be here in twenty years, in one condition or another. The economics of taking care of it are demanding, public, and they reward people who plan for them in time.

More from Robert Izsak