Insights
Robert Izsak on Energy Upgrades for Older New York City Buildings
I am Robert Izsak, a real estate owner in Brooklyn, and I have a practical interest in how older New York City buildings use energy. Heat, hot water, and electricity are among the costs that arrive every month, and they are also among the conditions people feel directly in their apartments. In an older building, energy is not a separate subject from upkeep. It is one of the ways the building either works or does not.
New York City has also made energy use a matter of regulation for many larger properties. It is worth understanding that framework in general terms, then returning to the upgrades that make sense whether or not a given building is covered.
What Local Law 97 actually requires
Local Law 97 of 2019 is part of the city’s Climate Mobilization Act. According to the Department of Buildings, buildings account for more than two-thirds of city greenhouse gas emissions. The law’s stated goal is to reduce emissions from the city’s largest buildings 40 percent by 2030 and to reach net zero by 2050.
Coverage is based on size, as recorded by the Department of Finance. In general, the law covers a building of more than 25,000 gross square feet, and also groups of buildings on the same tax lot, or condominiums under the same board, that together exceed 50,000 square feet. Many smaller rental buildings in Brooklyn will not meet those thresholds. Owners should not assume coverage, or the lack of it, without checking the official record.
For most private buildings that are covered, Article 320 requires an annual emissions report, certified by a registered design professional, and sets emissions limits that began with calendar year 2024, with stricter limits in 2030. A related path, Article 321, applies to certain affordable housing and houses of worship. Reports are due May 1 for the prior calendar year, with a 60-day period after that date during which a late report that shows compliance is not subject to the late-filing penalty.
The published civil penalty for exceeding an Article 320 emissions limit is the excess emissions, in metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent, multiplied by $268 for the year. A failure to file can bring a penalty of 50 cents per square foot of gross floor area for each month the report remains unfiled, subject to the rules in the law. The Department of Buildings is the authority on how those provisions are applied. Anyone with a covered property should rely on current official guidance and a qualified professional, not on a general article.
Efficiency still matters in buildings the law does not cover
A building that sits under the 25,000-square-foot threshold is not excused from the physics of an old envelope or an aging boiler. Fuel still costs money. Uneven heat still produces complaints in one apartment and open windows in another. Local Law 97 is a reason for some owners to measure and reduce emissions. It is not the only reason to run a tighter building. The useful question, in a property of any size, is simpler than a compliance spreadsheet: where is the energy going, and what would reduce waste without making the building harder to live in?
Start with the system you already have
In many older New York buildings, the heating plant is the largest energy user, and the system residents feel first. Before anyone talks about a full replacement, there is usually unglamorous work worth doing: a proper service, a check of controls and distribution, and, in steam buildings, the slow task of making heat more even across the property. A boiler that short-cycles or a radiator that never gets balanced will spend fuel and still leave people cold.
The same logic applies to domestic hot water, leaks in distribution piping, and common-area lighting. Lighting is often the easiest improvement to explain: newer fixtures use less electricity and fail less often. Air sealing, insulation where it can be done without trapping moisture, and a window that actually closes are not dramatic projects. They are often the difference between a room that holds heat and a room that does not.
I would be cautious about promising a particular savings percentage. Buildings differ, and a number pulled from another property is not a fact about yours. What can be said honestly is that waste is visible once you look for it, and that the first dollars are often better spent on tuning and sealing than on equipment the rest of the building is not ready to support.
Measure, then decide
You cannot manage what you never look at. Fuel bills and a simple record of service calls already tell a story. For larger buildings, city benchmarking and Local Law 97 reporting are formal versions of the same idea. For smaller ones, a consistent filing habit may be enough to show whether last winter cost more because the weather was harder, or because the building was.
New York City also maintains NYC Accelerator, a public advisory program to help owners understand energy improvements and related laws. It is a place to start when you need a map, not a substitute for the professional who will eventually sign or install the work.
The 2030 limits under Local Law 97 are stricter than the first compliance period. Owners of covered buildings who wait until the year before a tighter limit will have fewer good options. Owners of uncovered buildings do not have that deadline, but they have the same equipment life cycles. A boiler, a roof, and a set of windows will come due on their own schedule. The efficient version of those replacements is easier to choose when you have already reduced waste around them.
Energy work, done calmly, is maintenance with a longer view. Start with the facts of the property, use official sources for the law, and spend first on the improvements that make the building both cheaper to run and more comfortable to live in.